Restarting From the Wrong Word

When a route fails, restart from the start word, not from the deepest point you reached.

Mistake notes · 320 words

A failed route has two possible restart points, and the one that feels sensible is usually the wrong one. The instinct is to restart from the deepest word reached, because that point was hard-won and is close to the target. The better restart is the start word, which feels like throwing away progress.

The reason is that the deep word is the most committed point on the route that already failed. It shares a chain of assumptions with the wrong plan. Restarting there keeps all of those assumptions and removes only the last one, which is a small change to a large mistake. Restarting from the start keeps none of them and forces the search to justify itself again.

There is an exception. If the failure happened on the very last move and every earlier move is known to be sound, restarting at the last junction is efficient and legitimate. The test is whether you can explain why each earlier move was correct, without referring to the route's overall story. If you cannot, the deep restart is a bargain with a plan that has already lost.

The practical version of this rule is a short list. Write the route down, mark the move where it became wrong, and restart from one move before the first move that was only needed by the failed idea. That is almost always much earlier than the deepest point, and it is the most honest restart you can make.

The wrong word is usually the one you were most pleased with, which is exactly why it deserves the most suspicion.

Practicing the restart is easy because it needs no new boards: take a round you already failed and replay it from three different restart points. Then go and keep playing with the rule in mind. The restart is where most of the route's real learning happens, and it is the part most players skip.